This might be the weakest sci-fi premise ever – definitely the weakest to serve xenophobia

All right, you remember Yozakura Quartet, right?

The premise there was that magic worked, demons were real. Thus normal, non-magical people wanted all the demon people to live in a ghetto-city set aside for demons. That premise was a very believable approach to urban fantasy. Japanese people can be pretty xenophobic, and one could easily imagine the Japanese government going along with a plan to make demons into the next version of Okinawans – i.e. lower-class people with no money and no political power.

Now we have World Trigger, a show that tries to use a similar premise but fails miserably.
vlcsnap-2014-10-05-15h21m20s35

Premise: A dimensional gate opens in Mikado City and extra-dimensional sci-fi aliens called “NEIGHBORS” invade through it.

The Japanese army has little success in stopping them.

A mysterious organization, BORDER, appears, fights the aliens effectively, and even though the gate stays open, most of the population decides to stay in Mikado City. Incidentally they build a huge fortress overnight, and no one bothers them about land use rights.

And … the Japanese government … is supposed to be silent while all this happens. There’s an extra-dimensional menace, the army is powerless, and the only defenders of Japan are mysterious strangers. And the Japanese government just sits back and ignores this.

The sci-fi trappings don’t change the essence of the story. The two main characters are a fish-out-of-water boke and a tsukkomi, designed to appeal to young teenagers. They are both straight males, so their friendship/bromance is going to be G-rated.


Now, you might reasonably object that Beyond the Border had a premise that was almost as weak, and served a nearly-identical purpose of giving a meaningful backdrop to the angsty teenage romance that formed the meat of the story. Yes, but that story had romance, plus a sexy cosplaying demon-mom showing up for comic relief and fan service.
momakihito

[JN] Kyoukai no Kanata - 11 (1280x720 Hi10P AAC) [ED53F4D2].mkv_snapshot_17.58_[2013.12.15_01.53.15]

I don’t see nearly enough fan service in World Trigger to keep me watching a sci-fi-monsters-invade-the-school show. By contrast, the second episode of Karen Senki has very believable human behavior and human stupidity. The tech approaches sheer Hollywood action-extravaganza levels of silliness, but I can forgive that if the visuals are good.

One thought on “This might be the weakest sci-fi premise ever – definitely the weakest to serve xenophobia

  1. I will admit that episode one of World Trigger appeared a little weak, but I found it entertaining enough to give the second episode a shot. Sometimes a show needs 2 or 3 episodes to warm up–or seven for that matter! Remember Claymore? But, I will admit that both the premise and the characters seem cliche.

    Like

Comments Might Work, But We Won't Know Until You Try

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.